Liberman Faces Skepticism Over New Haredi Draft Law Pledge
Yisrael Beytenu leader Avigdor Liberman promises a conscription bill satisfying the IDF, High Court, and haredi leadership, but analysts question the feasibility of such a compromise.
By Luis Fernandez ·

Minutes after assuming the chairmanship of the Knesset’s temporary Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee on Monday, Yisrael Beytenu leader Avigdor Liberman pledged to introduce a fair conscription law. He stated that the bill would undergo three stages of validation, ensuring it meets the standards of the IDF chief of staff, the High Court of Justice, and Degel HaTorah spiritual leader Rabbi Lando.
The promise has drawn significant skepticism from political observers. To craft legislation acceptable to these three distinct entities, Liberman would need to act as a political magician and consensus builder. After three decades in politics, he is widely recognized more as a political survivor and disruptor than as a unifier. He has navigated numerous controversies, including criminal investigations, an indictment for fraud and breach of trust that ended in acquittal, and the convictions of senior party figures in a separate corruption case.
Liberman’s political career is marked by bold and often controversial proposals. He previously suggested bombing the Aswan Dam in 2001 and issued a 48-hour ultimatum to Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh in 2016 regarding the return of Israeli hostages. He also proposed conditioning Arab Israeli citizenship rights on a pledge of loyalty and military service, as well as redrawing national borders to exclude major Arab population centers. More recently, he blocked Benjamin Netanyahu from forming a government in 2019 over the haredi draft issue, triggering a cycle of repeated elections.
Now, Liberman is disrupting the political landscape again by reversing his stance on the haredi draft. This volte-face interferes with Yashar chairman Gadi Eisenkot’s efforts to form a minority government with outside support from Arab parties. While some compare this move to Naftali Bennett’s 2021 reversal of his campaign promise to prevent Yair Lapid from serving as prime minister, the difference lies in Liberman’s long-standing persona. For years, he has positioned himself against the haredi parties, demanding yeshiva students join the army and challenging their Shabbat practices. This new approach contrasts sharply with his previous declaration that he wanted police to pursue Rabbi Lando for advising students to ignore draft orders.
The feasibility of Liberman’s proposed law is questionable given the vast differences between the three required stakeholders. The IDF currently faces a shortfall of approximately 12,000 soldiers, including 7,500 in combat roles, and relies on haredi conscription to fill these ranks. In June 2024, the High Court of Justice ruled that once the exemption for yeshiva students expired, the government must apply the existing draft law equally to them to avoid discriminatory enforcement. The court’s decision specifically addressed yeshiva students, leaving the issue of Arab citizens' service as a separate matter.
Rabbi Lando’s position remains firm. In February 2026, he vowed at a yeshiva in Rehovot that not a single yeshiva student would enter the army. His maximum position extends to ensuring that no haredi individual, even those not in yeshiva frameworks, dons a military uniform. Bridging the gap between the IDF’s need for personnel, the court’s ruling on equal application, and Lando’s exemption demands presents a gargantuan legislative challenge.
Liberman also faces internal opposition within his own coalition. B’Yachad, the party led by Naftali Bennett, has already presented a bill to expand benefits for reservists and discharged soldiers. This initiative is funded partly by cutting support for households that neither serve in the military nor participate in the workforce. Liran Avisar Ben Horin, who heads the temporary Finance Committee, stated that her committee will promote a revolution for those who serve and work, aiming to return taxpayer money to them and halt payments that incentivize draft evasion.
During the committee session, Lando’s representative, Ya'akov Asher, interrupted Avisar Ben Horin’s remarks, calling the proposal a joke. Liberman’s new bill must now navigate a fourth hurdle beyond the three originally cited: opposition from his own camp. While this internal friction might seem like the easiest obstacle to overcome, it remains an extremely difficult task for the Knesset chairman to manage.






