Ryan McCartan Leads Indie Crime Drama 'Only Good Feelings' in 2027 New York Run
The Broadway actor will star in a limited theatrical release of the crime drama, which follows a man grappling with guilt and a dangerous plan to escape his past.
By Luis Fernandez ·

Ryan McCartan is set to make his theatrical debut as a leading man in the independent crime drama 'Only Good Feelings.' The actor, who recently concluded his starring role as Jay Gatsby in the Broadway production of 'The Great Gatsby,' will headline the film's limited New York engagement scheduled for February 2027. SNR Films is handling the distribution of the title for this upcoming run.
The cast of the film features a mix of television and theater talent. Elias Kacavas, known for his work on 'Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin,' joins McCartan in the lead roles. The ensemble also includes Heather Burns, previously seen in 'Manchester by the Sea,' and Ajay Naidu, who appeared in the film 'Office Space.' Amanda Steele and Ryan Whitney Newman, both recognized for their roles in 'See Dad Run,' round out the main cast.
The project was directed by Shervin Nassi, who also co-wrote the screenplay alongside Grant Schumacher. Michael Marlon is listed among the producers for the film. The story was shot entirely within New York City, grounding the narrative in a familiar urban landscape for the characters involved.
According to the official logline, the plot centers on Benny, played by McCartan, who is consumed by guilt following the death of his fiancée in a car accident. As his mental state deteriorates, he reconnects with Kam, a troubled childhood friend portrayed by Kacavas. Together, they devise a desperate scheme involving robbery, insurance fraud, and extortion to facilitate their escape to Mexico.
The narrative arc suggests that what starts as a simple plan for escape quickly transforms into a collision course with the very elements Benny has been trying to avoid. The dynamic between the two protagonists serves as the driving force of the story, highlighting themes of desperation and consequence.
The film has already gained recognition within the festival community. It secured the award for best narrative film at the Manhattan Film Festival and took home the best directorial debut honor at the Chicago Indie Film Awards. These accolades have helped build momentum for the theatrical release.
In 2026, 'Only Good Feelings' continued its tour of the independent film circuit. The title was selected for screening at several notable events, including the San Francisco Jewish Film Festival and the Dallas Movie Fest. It also featured at the SoCal Film Awards and the San Diego Independent Cinema Awards, further establishing its presence in the indie sector.
McCartan has a well-established background in musical theater. He made his Broadway debut in 2018 in the role of Fiyero in 'Wicked.' Subsequently, in 2020, he stepped into the role of Hans in the Broadway production of 'Frozen.' His career has spanned both stage and screen, demonstrating versatility in his acting choices.
Prior to his recent work on Broadway, McCartan's most recent on-screen credit was in the 2022 CW thriller series 'The Winchesters.' This experience in television drama may inform his approach to the more grounded and intense character of Benny in 'Only Good Feelings.'
The upcoming release represents a significant step for McCartan in the realm of non-musical theatrical work. By taking on a lead role in a crime drama, he expands his portfolio beyond the musicals that have defined much of his stage career to date.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






