AdvertiseDonate
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
City news, clearly told.
Hot Report Digest · 393 State Street, Salem, OR 97301

Gotham FC to host semifinal in 5,000-seat venue after pitch dispute

The club is leaving its 25,000-seat home to play on Randall's Island after safety concerns over the turf at Sports Illustrated Stadium.

By Luis Fernandez ·

Illustration for: Gotham FC to host semifinal in 5,000-seat venue after pitch dispute
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Gotham FC will play Sunday's NWSL semifinal against the Kansas City Current in a 5,000-seat stadium. The late relocation to Icahn Stadium on Manhattan's Randall's Island follows safety concerns about the playing surface at the club's usual home. Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, N.J., has a capacity of 25,000 and has hosted Gotham since 2021.

The move was decided after Gotham defeated the Seattle Reign 1-0 in the quarterfinals. Head coach Juan Carlos Amoros said he felt an obligation to apologize for the state of the pitch. He added that the league should be providing a better surface. Captain Tierna Davidson stated that the team worked hard to earn a home playoff berth. She called the reduced capacity the hardest part of the decision.

The dispute stems from the shared use of the stadium by MLS side Red Bull New York. RBNY installed a new pitch during a World Cup break, a surface that won a professional soccer award from the Sports Turf Management Association in 2021. Gotham raised concerns with the venue operators before a Nov. 1 match. The complaints cited visible damage from a USA Rugby Fall Series doubleheader held on Oct. 30.

The NWSL fined Gotham $10,000 for the field's condition, even though the club does not manage the venue. The NWSL Players Association said it was unaware of the penalty. A source noted that RBNY was also unaware until Seattle coach Laura Harvey mentioned it after the quarterfinal.

League officials and referees deemed the pitch playable on Sunday morning. A field consultant said it met FIFA standards. Players disagreed with that assessment. Seattle captain Jess Fishlock called the surface atrocious. Gotham midfielder Jaelin Howell described it as sandy and unstable. Attacker Jaedyn Shaw expressed worry that her planted foot would slip on corner kicks. Sand and faint rugby lines remained visible on the field.

Gotham and the NWSL discussed fixes with RBNY after the quarterfinal. Options included re-sodding or adding artificial threads to the grass. RBNY declined to proceed because the league could not guarantee completion before a Saturday friendly against Club America. RBNY stated in a statement that the pitch was cleared for every match this season and that experts could not guarantee timely repairs. The club plans to play its friendly on the same surface without changes.

Icahn Stadium is not unfamiliar to Gotham. The club hosted a Concacaf W Champions Cup game there in August 2025. Amoros called that pitch outstanding at the time. The venue switch adds to scheduling strains in the postseason. The Boston Legacy will shift home games to Pawtucket, R.I., for the 2027 season while White Stadium is built.

More Sports · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Hot Report Digest in your inboxCity news, clearly told. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get Hot Report Digest in your inboxCity news, clearly told. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.